Skip to main content
A change of circumstance (or changed circumstance) is a specific event or new information that, under TRID and Regulation Z, allows a creditor to issue a revised Loan Estimate with updated fees or terms. When a revised Loan Estimate is properly issued because of a valid change of circumstance, it becomes the new baseline for tolerance comparison at closing—so the creditor is not locked to the original estimate for those charges. Valid changes of circumstance are limited by regulation. Creditors cannot use them to deliberately underestimate fees and then “fix” them later; the reason for the revision must be genuine and supported by the facts.

​
Why it matters

  • Tolerance baseline — Fees on the initial Loan Estimate are subject to tolerance bands (zero, 10%, or unlimited). If closing costs exceed those tolerances, a tolerance cure is owed. A valid change of circumstance allows the creditor to issue a revised Loan Estimate, which resets the baseline: closing is then compared to the revised LE, not the original.
  • Good faith — Revised estimates must still be made in good faith. The creditor must have a valid reason (one of the categories below) and must not use changed circumstances as a way to circumvent tolerance rules by intentionally under-disclosing.

​
Valid reasons for a revised Loan Estimate

The following are the main categories of valid changes of circumstance under Regulation Z. When one of these occurs, the creditor may issue a revised Loan Estimate and update the disclosed fees or terms accordingly.

​
Changed circumstances affecting settlement charges

New or different information that affects the accuracy of settlement charges disclosed on the Loan Estimate. Examples include:
  • Information the creditor relied on was inaccurate — The creditor relied on information (e.g. from the borrower, a third party, or public records) that later turns out to be wrong, and the correct information leads to different settlement charges.
  • Information the creditor did not rely on — The creditor receives new information that it did not have and did not rely on when issuing the original Loan Estimate, and that information affects settlement charges.
  • Extraordinary events beyond anyone’s control — Events such as natural disasters, war, or other extraordinary circumstances that affect the cost or availability of services (e.g. a pandemic that increases the cost of appraisals or other third-party services). The CFPB has stated that the COVID-19 pandemic qualified as such an event.
In each case, the revised charges must be based on the new or corrected information and disclosed in good faith.

​
Changed circumstances affecting eligibility

Circumstances that affect the consumer’s eligibility for the loan, the value of the property, or other eligibility-related terms. Examples include:
  • Appraisal or property value — The property is appraised for less than the sales price or the value the creditor used, affecting loan terms or eligibility.
  • Income or employment — The creditor cannot document income that was stated or relied on (e.g. overtime, bonus, or irregular income), or there is a material change in the consumer’s employment or income.
  • Credit or eligibility — New or revised credit information or other eligibility criteria that the creditor did not rely on initially, or that has changed.
When eligibility is affected, the creditor may need to change the loan product, amount, or terms and issue a revised Loan Estimate reflecting the new scenario.

​
Consumer-requested changes

The consumer asks for a change to the loan or transaction. Examples include:
  • Different loan type or product — The consumer requests a different loan product (e.g. switching from one product to another).
  • Different loan amount or down payment — The consumer requests a different loan amount or down payment.
  • Rate lock — The consumer requests a rate lock after the initial Loan Estimate was provided. Interest rate–dependent charges (e.g. per diem interest, some lender fees tied to the rate) may then be updated on a revised Loan Estimate to reflect the locked rate.
These are not “changed circumstances” in the sense of new information, but the regulation treats consumer-requested changes as a valid basis for issuing a revised estimate and resetting the baseline where applicable.

​
Expiration of the original Loan Estimate

The quoted fee expiration date on the original Loan Estimate has passed. Loan Estimates are valid for a limited period (e.g. a specified number of business days). After that date, the creditor may issue a new Loan Estimate with updated fees if the consumer has not yet proceeded, and that new estimate becomes the baseline.

​
Delayed settlement (construction loans)

For construction loans, a delayed settlement date can be a valid reason to issue a revised Loan Estimate under the rules that apply to construction financing. The delay may affect fees or terms, and the revised LE then serves as the new baseline.

​
What is not a valid change of circumstance

  • Deliberately underestimating fees — Creditors cannot lowball fees on the initial Loan Estimate and then issue a “revised” estimate to avoid tolerance cures. Estimates must be made in good faith based on the best information reasonably available at the time.
  • Routine market changes — General market or rate movements, without a consumer-requested rate lock or other triggering event, do not by themselves justify a revised estimate for the purpose of resetting tolerances in the way a valid change of circumstance does.
  • Convenience — The creditor cannot issue a revised Loan Estimate solely to reset the baseline for administrative convenience; there must be a valid reason under the regulation.

​
Relation to tolerance and cures

When a valid change of circumstance (or other permitted trigger) occurs and the creditor issues a revised Loan Estimate:
  1. The revised Loan Estimate becomes the new baseline for tolerance at closing.
  2. Closing costs are compared to the amounts on the revised LE, not the original.
  3. If fees at closing still exceed the tolerances relative to the revised LE, a tolerance cure is owed.
Pylon is responsible for all tolerance cures and represents and warrants the file. Lenders using Pylon do not need to implement change-of-circumstance logic for cure liability; the expectation is that fees are set within tolerance at disclosure and that revised estimates are used only when appropriate under the rules.